Tuesday, 2009-10-13

*** nathany has quit IRC00:34
*** JED3 has quit IRC00:36
*** stevel has quit IRC00:40
*** pyrak has joined #cc01:01
jibotpyrak is Parker Phinney and madebyparker.com and a sophomore at Dartmouth and a former CC tech intern01:01
*** akozak has quit IRC01:02
*** tim_hwang has joined #cc01:08
jibottim_hwang is the awesome duder behind ROFLCon and is working to define the rules of the electronic internets. Will likely host Robot Whores if/when a pilot is made.01:08
*** JoiIto has quit IRC01:31
*** everton137 has joined #cc01:44
*** JavaWoman has quit IRC02:19
*** JavaWoman has joined #cc02:20
*** cmwslw has joined #cc02:40
*** cmwslw has left #cc02:46
*** [mharrison] has joined #cc03:14
*** tim_hwang has quit IRC03:20
*** sama has joined #cc05:13
*** mlinksva has quit IRC05:31
*** pyrak has quit IRC05:46
*** JoiIto has joined #cc06:30
jibotJoiIto is blogging at http://joi.ito.com/ and the CEO of Creative Commons06:30
*** sama has quit IRC06:34
*** pyrak has joined #cc06:42
jibotpyrak is Parker Phinney and madebyparker.com and a sophomore at Dartmouth and a former CC tech intern06:42
*** Kaetemi has joined #cc06:50
*** wormsxulla_ has joined #cc07:14
*** wormsxulla has quit IRC07:16
*** wormsxulla_ is now known as wormsxulla07:16
*** sama has joined #cc07:36
*** pyrak has quit IRC07:41
*** JoiIto has quit IRC08:39
*** Kaetemi has quit IRC10:44
*** Roderick has joined #CC10:53
*** Kaetemi has joined #cc11:35
*** jwyg has joined #cc11:55
*** JoiIto has joined #cc12:01
jibotJoiIto is blogging at http://joi.ito.com/ and the CEO of Creative Commons12:01
*** Roderick has quit IRC12:09
*** JoiIto has quit IRC12:28
*** tvol has joined #cc13:17
*** mlinksva has joined #cc14:26
jibotmlinksva is from Creative Commons and Mike Linksvayer14:26
*** nkinkade has joined #cc14:45
*** kalin__ has joined #CC15:08
*** nathany has joined #cc15:09
*** jgay has joined #cc15:50
jibotjgay is http://www.gnu.org/people/speakers.html#Gay15:50
*** stevel has joined #cc16:06
*** akozak has joined #cc16:37
jibotakozak is Alex Kozak, Program Assistant at ccLearn and SFC@Berkeley co-founder and a norse god16:37
*** JED3 has joined #cc16:38
*** sama has quit IRC16:55
*** johndoigiii has joined #cc17:04
*** jwyg has quit IRC17:16
*** tim_hwang has joined #cc17:17
jibottim_hwang is the awesome duder behind ROFLCon and is working to define the rules of the electronic internets. Will likely host Robot Whores if/when a pilot is made.17:17
*** EvanCarroll has joined #cc17:21
EvanCarrollwould using a work in a commercial be consider a "commercial" use, or is commercial use just in reference to reselling and direct profiting from the work?17:21
*** JED3 has quit IRC17:23
*** johndoigiii is now known as JED317:23
EvanCarroll"primarily intended for or directed toward commercial advantage"17:23
EvanCarrollthis is so vague.17:23
akozakEvanCarroll: CC recently put put a study on the topic. http://wiki.creativecommons.org/Defining_Noncommercial17:24
EvanCarrollyea, i'm reading that17:28
EvanCarrollthis is ridiciolus.17:28
*** jwyg has joined #cc17:30
EvanCarroll225 pages to figure out if NC permits use in an advertisement by a for-profit company that has no intention of reselling the work or profiting directly from it17:32
*** JoiIto has joined #cc17:34
jibotJoiIto is blogging at http://joi.ito.com/ and the CEO of Creative Commons17:34
nkinkadeEvanCarroll: Not precisely ridiculous, but just a testament to the fact that there are no easy answers.17:35
nkinkadePeople like black and white, but it just doesn't and cannot exist in this case.17:35
akozakEvanCarroll: I know this might not be a very satisfying suggestion. but if you have one particular work in mind one possibility would be to contact the owner of the work and ask them what they consider commercial or non-commercial use to be, or to ask them for permission to use it commercially.17:38
*** JoiIto has quit IRC17:38
akozakEvanCarroll: Or you could find similar works without the NC term.17:38
EvanCarrollakozak: let me rephriase, if the consumers of the work aren't sure if they're going to get sued or if they're violating the law, it is a partial failure, it is a total failure.17:40
EvanCarrollNC is either providing a solutiotn, or creating a massive problem.17:40
EvanCarrollit isn't a partial*17:40
EvanCarrollmy situation is this, my company is comming out with another product where by we sell a video-camera with mic in so car dealerships can record videos of this vehicles for use in advertisments, and to place on youtube.17:41
EvanCarrollwe're going to record an audio advertisment for them, and put background music up for it.17:42
EvanCarrollWe're trying to find out if -NC can work with us.17:42
EvanCarrollwe're not selling their music, we're just giving away some prerecorded audio as part of our services.17:42
EvanCarrollgranted, we're making money, and their audio could be construed as helping17:43
akozakEvanCarroll: Aside from if NC allows that, do you have a compelling reason to use NC work? There is probably a lot of non-NC Creative Commons licensed music out there.17:44
EvanCarrollthe pool of +NC work is *much* larger, and I don't see a way to sort by -NC ccmixter.org17:49
EvanCarrollso if NC allows it is very much the question17:50
akozakEvanCarroll: it's important to remember that when a work has an NC term, that represents the wishes of the copyright holder. So while we do everything we can to clarify the term, e.g. putting out that rather large and comprehensive study, there is necessarily some ambiguity in the wishes of the rights holder.17:52
akozakAnd commercial or non-commercial has never been an easy term to define throughout the history of legal analysis.17:52
akozakHave you tried using cc search?17:53
EvanCarroll?17:53
EvanCarrollnope17:53
akozakhttp://search.creativecommons.org/17:53
akozakTry searching Jamendo and SpinXpress17:54
EvanCarrollI'm looking for music17:55
EvanCarrollah17:55
EvanCarrolli see17:55
EvanCarrollhttp://www.jamendo.com/en/album/716817:56
EvanCarrolltook me there17:56
EvanCarrollekk17:56
akozakEvanCarroll: Also check out http://wiki.creativecommons.org/Content_Directories17:56
EvanCarrollwait17:56
EvanCarrollit says that is CC, but the record has a license this record button17:56
akozakEvanCarroll: We aren't a part of Jamendo so I can't advise on that.17:57
EvanCarrollekk17:58
EvanCarrollso this is CC music, or just the page content is CC17:58
EvanCarrollthis looks like a sham, if licensing this is going to cost me but is permitted within the license17:58
akozakEvanCarroll: If you have any questions about Jamendo I'd recommend you contact them.17:59
EvanCarrollwhy are they on search.creativecommons.org if their music isn't CC, lol17:59
EvanCarrollI will certainly never use another creative commons license in my life.18:02
EvanCarrollthis has been the most negatively enlightening license experience ever.18:02
EvanCarrollno one has an idea how any of these made-for-idiots licenses work, everyone -- including the people linked to on creativecommons -- are trying to abuse and misguide the users of them, there is no even halfway decent search engine.18:03
EvanCarrollit is really laughable for everything excluding the concept of a point-and-click licsense builder which is such a good idea I doubt it is new to CC.18:03
paroneayeaI think it's pretty simple... if you're using the music in an ad (which is commercial), and you don't want to pay for it,18:04
paroneayeadon't use -NC18:04
paroneayeapretty simple!18:04
EvanCarrollright, so simple that you need a 250 page report to summarize a few opinion polls done a year ago.18:07
paroneayeacreative commons is trying to solve a problem domain of liensing that many people want and need.18:07
paroneayeaif that doesn't apply to you18:07
paroneayeadon't use it18:07
paroneayeameanwhile, if you do want to use it, there is -nc stuff that you could contact authors about, and some stuff that isn't even -nc where you don't even have to (granted, if it's a sharealike license, you are also obliged to release yours under the same license)18:09
*** johndoigiii has joined #cc18:11
*** JED3 has quit IRC18:12
*** johndoigiii is now known as JED318:12
*** michi has joined #cc18:49
akozakvery cool: http://ignorethecode.net/blog/2009/10/13/10_gui/18:51
*** [mharrison] has quit IRC19:26
*** michi__ has joined #cc19:46
*** tim_hwang has quit IRC19:50
*** michi has quit IRC19:53
*** tvol has quit IRC19:57
*** johndoigiii has joined #cc20:08
paroneayeanathany: ping20:14
nathanyparoneayea: pong20:14
paroneayeaso, in the old engine/licenses/standard.py20:16
paroneayeathere's the "conditions" method of LicenseDeed20:16
paroneayeaand it says that this predicate mapping should "really be a part of cc.license"20:16
paroneayeaso, how do you envision that working now?  Or does it already work?20:16
nathanyparoneayea: i suspect it'll already work or be close to it...20:17
nathanybasically right now standard.py needs to know which predicates (URIs) are part of each license20:17
nathanyand right now that's duplicated in the RDF and in standard.py20:17
nathanyso i think my thought was we should get those predicates from cc.license directly (since they're in the RDF)20:18
nathanythe one wrinkle may be that we split up the predicates between "you are free" and "with the following restrictions"20:19
nathanynot sure where that distinction/filtering comes into play20:19
akozakDAMNIT someone stole my million dollar idea: http://thewikireader.com/20:21
paroneayeanathany: ok, cool... thanks :)20:22
paroneayeaakozak: oh neat, that's what the openmoko team is working on then?20:22
akozaklooks like it...20:23
*** jwyg has quit IRC20:23
akozakI really want to compete with them with my git-based wikipedia sync system.20:24
akozak(theoretical)20:24
*** JED3 has quit IRC20:25
*** johndoigiii is now known as JED320:25
paroneayeaI wonder how useful it'll be as a general purpose, free software friendly e-reader20:27
*** johndoigiii has joined #cc20:28
akozakI hope their next iteration adds the ability to edit.20:29
akozakor maybe I don't, so that I can beat them to it20:29
*** michi__ has quit IRC20:33
paroneayealooks like it has an onscreen keyboard20:35
paroneayeaand it looks updatable via microsd20:35
akozakdamn!20:35
akozakmokoooooo!20:35
paroneayeasince it's openmoko, inc, I assume that it'll be a hackable device20:36
paroneayeawow, only $9920:36
*** JED3 has quit IRC20:57
*** johndoigiii is now known as JED320:57
*** jgay has quit IRC21:01
*** akozak has quit IRC21:06
*** pyrak has joined #cc21:09
jibotpyrak is Parker Phinney and madebyparker.com and a sophomore at Dartmouth and a former CC tech intern21:09
*** wormsxulla has quit IRC21:17
*** wormsxulla_ has joined #cc21:18
*** wormsxulla_ is now known as wormsxulla21:18
*** Roderick has joined #CC21:32
*** jgay has joined #cc22:18
jibotjgay is http://www.gnu.org/people/speakers.html#Gay22:18
paroneayeanathany: okay, so I'm looking at the way that you figure out the titles / descriptions of each condition22:28
paroneayeaand so, I've figured out how to do it22:28
paroneayeavia getting the msgctxt22:29
paroneayeabut maybe we should add some "generic" way of pulling that from cc.license?22:29
nathanyparoneayea: you mean you construct the translation key and just use that to pull from the PO files?22:30
paroneayeayeah22:30
nathany(just want to make sure I understand what you're doing ATM)22:30
paroneayeamaybe there should be a generic function for querying/retrieving that?22:31
nathanyi agree that it'd be good to get that from cc.license.  Can we just add it to a list of "things we need to make better" and keep moving forward? I'd like to get a basically working version that has tests, uses repoze.bfg, etc and then iterate on that22:31
nathanyright22:31
paroneayeayeah22:31
paroneayeaok :)22:31
nathanythanks22:33
paroneayeanathany: also, I am trying to figure out the "proper" way to map say,22:36
paroneayea>>> by_rdf.requires22:36
paroneayea('http://creativecommons.org/ns#Attribution', 'http://creativecommons.org/ns#Notice')22:36
paroneayeamap 'http://creativecommons.org/ns#Attribution' to 'by'22:36
paroneayeaI think I can just take the fragment there and use that as the msgid for translation, but22:37
paroneayeathe old way generated the keys by splitting the code of the license22:38
paroneayealike 'by-sa-nd'.split('-')22:38
paroneayeaand then used each of those to generate the msgctxt, like 'char.by_title'22:38
paroneayeaI'm wondering if there's any clear mapping between 'http://creativecommons.org/ns#Attribution' -> 'by'22:39
paroneayeasomewhere22:39
paroneayeait doesn't appear that there is22:42
*** nathany has quit IRC22:44
*** pyrak has quit IRC22:46
paroneayea:x22:50
*** Kaetemi has quit IRC23:05
*** pyrak has joined #cc23:19
jibotpyrak is Parker Phinney and madebyparker.com and a sophomore at Dartmouth and a former CC tech intern23:19
*** jgay has quit IRC23:37
*** tim_hwang has joined #cc23:38
jibottim_hwang is the awesome duder behind ROFLCon and is working to define the rules of the electronic internets. Will likely host Robot Whores if/when a pilot is made.23:38
*** stevel has quit IRC23:53

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.6 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!